So, the FDA passed a bill last night officially declaring that cloned meat is safe to eat. Now, I live in a house with my fair share of vegetarian / organic-eating roommates, so this caused quite a stir. Therefore, I’d like to offer my own thoughts…
So the controversy over cloned meat is multi-level: is it really safe, does it hurt the animal, does it have the potential for health risks, etc. Well the fact of the matter is, we’ve been doing things like this for a long time, and it’s never been a problem. Genetically engineered foods have been on the market for decades, and there is no scientific evidence that shows them to be harmful. And cloned meats are even less likely to cause a problem, because no DNA is actually being modified, just reproduced.
The way that the whole process works (from my understanding), is that a prize-cow is chosen, and DNA is extracted through blood cells. Through chemistry magic, the DNA is coerced into an embryo, and inserted into a female cow. It gestates for a while, and then finally, out pops a baby clone. Now, the clone isn’t actually used for meat– that would be too expensive. Instead, it’s bread with other fine steers, and the offspring are used for meat.
So this brings me to the point on animal treatment. The new clones are the most expensive cows on the farm, and thus treated like kings. As far as the cow that produces the clone, the process is comparable to artificial insemination, which has been going on for years. So, you can expect PETA to be all over this one– but it’s nothing new.
Then, the quality of food. The meat that hits our grocery stores isn’t going to be any worse or more dangerous than what we have now. There’s no new DNA being introduced, and what you’re eating is a naturally-born cow. In fact, if anything, there’s less chance of disease, because the offspring will be more uniform across the board. If they test one hamburger and it’s disease free, chances are the rest will be too.
So I guess the last thing to consider is the future– how does this bode for our future, the farmer’s future, and the future of cows as we know it (as we know them?). From the consumer perspective, we can expect cheaper, higher-quality meat. As the process is perfected and universally adopted, the cows will be cheaper to produce, and they will be selectively bread for prize cows every time. This brings us to the farmer; with new technology, he can expect bigger, healthier cows that he can sell for a higher profit. And as for the cows, each new clone will be selected for higher immunity against disease and to be healthy, happy cows. All in all, it’s a win-win-win situation.
PS: You actually have nothing to worry about just yet; although the FDA has deemed clones safe to eat, the Department of Agriculture has asked for a further ban on cloned meat, for at least 2 more years.
PPS: Check out that sweet graphic above. I made that using GIMP in Ubuntu– cool huh?